Beth Fileti (she/her)

April 2025
Brand strategy & copywriting

Five Wits

A premium haircare brand challenging the clutter of haircare advice

What I worked on:
  • Brand Strategy
  • Brand Guide
The whole map. In just a tap.
Work done for:
Five Wits / The Blackstones Collective
Brief

In anticipation of a Vogue write-up, Five Wits needed to define their brand and position through a website refresh.

Strategic Direction by Katie Hatfield, Brandsisters; Creative Direction by Eva Brandstötter-Reilly, Brandsisters

Brand Strategy & Copywriting

Challenges

  • Competition for premium haircare is high
  • Strong social media strategies are winning across all audiences
  • Small product range
  • Limited marketing budget
  • Biggest efficacy/product difference is between salon vs. drugstore. (Not between salon brands)

Key Differentiators

  • New York City. Five Wits was developed over time in a well-established Manhattan salon. The formula was developed in collaboration with demanding and particular New Yorkers. (Because if you want honest feedback, you ask a New Yorker.)
  • Aroma. The founder, Joey Silvestera, worked directly with luxury scent experts to develop two custom scents that facilitate a light, but sensory experience in the shower. (pepo + olive; fig + amber. Both smell amazing.)
  • Hotels/Fitness Centers. Five Wits has gotten a strong footing as the product of choice for high-end hotels and health clubs, including The Roxy in Manhattan and Life Time.
  • Joey Silvestera (founder/owner). Joey's approachable aesthetic and cool personality have been major factors in the success of his salon and haircare line. With a lowkey approach to celebrity and NYC beauty connections, the Five Wits brand would do well to mirror and extend his reach.
  • The Blackstones Collective (salon). The salon where Five Wits was developed is a known secret among celebrity clientele (including Chloë Sevigny, Hamish Bowles, Helen Mirren, Paul Banks, and Helena Christensen) for nailing NYC street style. Additionally, the salon has built a friendly network of fashion models, photographers, and influencers who could be tapped for modeling or social media engagement.
  • Simplicity. The products, lines, and categories are not fussy or complicated. Joey's philosophy around haircare is to help his clients stop listening to marketing and start listening to their hair.
  • Design. Five Wits packaging was simple, elegant, and straightforward.
  • Commitment to Sustainability. Joey proactively works to minimize the amount of plastic used in containers, promote recycling, and minimize the impact that Five Wits products have on the planet.

Insights

  • There is a nice overlap between a small product range, sustainability, and high-end curation. Using this lens, the small product line becomes a strength, and not a weakness.
  • Audiences are experiencing marketing overwhelm. Almost every company has a haircare quiz or complex numeric system for buyers to navigate through to find their particular product.
  • Audiences are being way oversold on the differences and impact between premium products.
  • Positioned as a challenger brand, Five Wits is more likely to get cut-thru in the sea of noise.
  • Long-term brand maintenance will be easier managed, if it is tonally similar to Joey's natural speaking style.
  • In a clutter-filled market, straightforward products feel easy and luxurious.
beth@politetype.com | 973-573-1931
© 2025, Polite Type